Page 72 - ICE BUSINESS TIMES January 2020
P. 72

WHY SHOULD YOU CARE?              provisioning. If profit is being        reasonable rates. This might                                                                                                     RIGHTING THE WRONG
             NPL is a reflection of the long-term   eaten up by NPL, then banks        also result in borrowers not                                                                                                     A comprehensive resolution
             financial health and sustainability   cannot keep provisions for long     getting loans due to liquidity                                                                                                   will require the government to
             of the banking sector. There are   and will eventually default on         crunch. A soaring NPL may                                                                                                        bite the bullet and do a proper
             four reasons behind this:         their obligations and go out of         also exacerbate the liquidity                                                                                                    restructuring of the banking
             1. Banking is a business. Unless   business. The economic                 crisis and banks’ ability to pay                                                                                                 sector based on a sound
                they earn money on their loans,   consequence of this will be          the money to its depositors,                                                                                                     diagnostic analysis of NPLs of
                they will not be able to stay in   devastating.                        which can potentially trigger                                                                                                    both public and private banks
                business. So, interest earned on   4. Lastly, there is considerable    the banks’ reputational risk.                                                                                                    and associated institutional
                total assets loans is a critical   global evidence that the                                                                                                                                             arrangements for regulation
                determinant of a bank's        financial health of the banking         HOW IS BANGLADESH BANK                                                                                                           and supervision. This
                financial sustainability.      sector is negatively correlated         RESPONDING?                                                                                                                      diagnosis should be done by a
             2. If NPL grows and banks face a   with the size of gross NPL. So,        In January 2015, a number of                                                                                                     team of experts who are
                threat to their profitability, they   the long-term viability of a     15 big group with more than Tk                                                                                                   independent and not involved
                will respond back by raising the   sound banking system depends        500 crore loans in default                                                                                                       with the present banking
                interest on loans that will    on keeping a tight lid on gross         enjoyed the facility getting their                                                                                               system.
                penalize good borrowers and    NPLs.                                   loans rescheduled. A total                                                                                                       A short-cut fix through loan
                hurt economic growth.        Furthermore, the huge amount of           amount of Tk16,410 crore                                                                                                         restructuring and redefinition
             3. Provisions can only be kept if   NPL will accelerate the operating     loans were rescheduled at that                                                                                                   of prudential norms will be
                banks earn money. The larger   costs of the banks, which will          time. Officials said the central                                                                                                 like applying band-aid to a
                the size of NPL, the larger the   increase the lending rates. This     bank decided not to reschedule                         writ with the High Court in favor of                                      cancer wound. Redefinition of
                amount of required           scenario will make it difficult for       loans below Tk 500 crore                                                                                                         prudential norms that are
                                             the good borrowers to get loans at        though the defaulters filed a                          their demand.                                                             presently aligned to
                                                                                                                                              One of the conditions of the                                              international norms can also
                                                                                                                                              rescheduling facility was that the                                        jeopardize the international
                                                                                                                                              borrowers would be marked                                                 credit risk perception of
                                                                                                                                              defaulters, and the benefit would                                         Bangladesh and must be
                                                                                                                                              be cancelled if they failed to pay                                        avoided. The solutions to the
                                                                                                                                              two consecutive instalments. In                                           NPL problem will need to make
                                                                                                                                              such cases, they would also be                                            a distinction between the stock                      FARMERS BANK SCANDAL                                                      bank's capital base. The law set
                                                                                                                                              barred from any loan rescheduling                                         of NPL and the future flow. The                      The Farmers Bank became a hotbed                                          the single borrower exposure
                                                                                                                                              benefit in the future. The special                                        growing stock of NPL suggests                        for financial irregularities, just                                        limit to 10%.
                                                                                                                                              rescheduling facilities offered to   This move by Bangladesh Bank has     that the stock problem cannot                        three years after commencing                                              Currently, Janata Bank has the
                                                                                                                                              the big defaulters did not do much   sent out a clear message to the      be resolved unless the flow                          operations, near the end of 2017.                                         most default loans, worth
                                                                                                                                              to curb NPL. Of the 11 business   borrowers that it is better to default   problem is addressed.                               Established in 2013, the bank was                                         Tk14,376.46 crore. Once
                                                                                                                                              groups, five have become        than to service the loans regularly.                                                           involved in siphoning off more                                            considered a strong performer
                                                                                                                                              defaulters again while most of the   Moreover, the burden of NPL has                                                           than Tk3,500 crore, according to                                          among the state-owned banks,
                                                                                                                                              11 groups had repeatedly been   often been transferred to the             Scams A Plenty                                       Bangladesh Bank. Currently, its                                           Janata Bank is going through
                                                                                                                                              defaulting on repayment. The    taxpayers through treasury                The roles of the government,                         NPLs account for 58% of its total                                         troubled times, former
                                                                                                                                              overall default loans of these 11   transfers.  This is not only          particularly the Ministry of                         outstanding loans.                                                        Bangladesh Bank Governor
                                                                                                                                              groups ballooned from Tk 15,180   unsustainable as tax revenues           Finance and Bangladesh Bank                          Muhiuddin Khan Alamgir, board                                             Salehuddin Ahmed has said
                                                                                                                                              crore in 2015 to Tk 17,103 crore in   become increasingly constrained, it   were largely limited to appease                    chairman, and Md Mahabubul      aforementioned financial                  there is no plan of action in
                                                                                                                                              2019.                           is also unethical. In Bangladesh          bank owners, as they                                 Haque Chisty, chairman of the   institutions were appointed as            sight to solve the crisis.
                                                                                                                                              Despite the disappointing results   where there are still millions of     succeeded to amend The Bank                          audit committee, were forced to   directors of The Farmers Bank.          Salehuddin cited a lack of good
                                                                                                                                              from the previous rescheduling   poor, using tax revenues to bail out     Company Act , 1991, reduce                           resign from their respective posts                                        governance and widespread
                                                                                                                                              policy, Bangladesh Bank introduced   public banks because they have       corporate tax, and manipulate                        in November, 2017—following                                               corruption as major reasons for
                                                                                                                                              a circular on 16 May 2019 which   loaned out depositor's money to         the pledged 9 % lending rate.                        corruption allegations. As a result,   JANATA BANK LOAN SCAM              the current dire situation of
                                                                                                                                              allowed rescheduling of credit   bad borrowers who often tend to be       In 2018, banks have no role in                       from January 2018, depositors   In August, 2018, a loan scam              Janata Bank. “The
                                                                                                                                              facilities of defaulter borrowers in   very rich and powerful would seem   stemming soaring NPLs,                              started withdrawing money from   perpetrated by state-owned Janata        politically-appointed bank
                                                                                                                                              more favorable terms than the   to violate all accepted norms of          instead, loan scams of a large                       the bank, prompting the central   Bank came to light. A Bangladesh        directors often influence bank
                                                                                                                                              credit facilities enjoyed by    ethics and morality.                      magnitude resurfaced in the                          bank and the government to step in   Bank report revealed that Janata     officials to sanction loans
                                                                                                                                              borrowers who have been repaying   Finally, restructuring is a means to   banking sector. Amid a                               and rescue the organization. Later,   bank had lent more than Tk10,000    which cannot be recovered
                                                                                                                                              regularly. The circular allowed   avoid the pain of an otherwise          proliferation of scheduled                           four state-owned commercial     crore to AnonTex and Crescent             later. Additionally, loyalty to
                                                                                                                                              defaulters to pay only a 2% down   good borrower facing unforeseen        banks, many of which have                            banks—Sonali Bank, Janata Bank,   Group without complying with the        vested groups, corruption, and
                                                                                                                                              payment to reschedule their loans   contingencies. It is not a solution   been incurring losses for years,                     Agrani Bank, and Rupali         central bank's single borrower            lack of experience—among a
                                                                                                                                              to avail a 10-year loan repayment   to the NPL problem. Unless it is      the BB stunned the sector by                         Bank—and the Investment         exposure limit criteria.                  section of bankers—worsens
                                                                                                                                              period with a one-year grace    addressed at the roots by resolving       giving permission to another                         Corporation of Bangladesh bailed   Janata Bank lent Tk5,500 crore to      the situation,” he further
                                                                                                                                              period. The rate of interest for   all the weaknesses in portfolio        new bank, Community Bank of                          out the bank, buying its equity   AnonTex—in clear violation of the       added.
                                                                                                                                              these defaulters have been capped   quality, the NPL problem will         Bangladesh, to operate.                              shares worth Tk715 crore.       Bank Company Act 1991—as it               Other ‘noteworthy’ scams
                                                                                                                                              at 9%.                          re-emerge.                                                                                     Managing directors of all five of the   provided 25% of the state-owned   includes the Basic Bank and

             66
   67   68   69   70   71   72   73   74   75   76   77